Start here
The Zest

Teacher trainings and certified instructors: letting others use your method name without losing it

Written by

You let certified instructors use your method name through one of two structures: a trademark license where you control the quality of what they teach, or a certification mark that certifies their teaching meets your standards. Either one works. What doesn't work is handing out the name with a certificate and never checking what happens next. A court can treat that as abandonment, and the name you built stops being yours.

What you're actually handing out

A teacher training usually gives graduates two things that people blur together. The first is the right to teach classes under your method name, like "Larkspur Method Pilates." The second is a credential, like "Certified Larkspur Instructor," that tells clients the teacher passed your program.

Trademark law treats those differently. The first is someone else using your service mark. The second is closer to what a certification mark does. Which structure fits depends on whether you also teach under the name yourself.

Option one: license the name and control the quality

The Lanham Act lets other people use your mark without weakening it, as long as you control them. It calls them related companies: "any person whose use of a mark is controlled by the owner of the mark with respect to the nature and quality of the goods or services." Under 15 U.S.C. § 1055, when a related company uses your mark legitimately, "such use shall not affect the validity of such mark or of its registration," and the use counts in your favor.

The Trademark Manual of Examining Procedure (TMEP) puts the whole idea in one sentence: "The essence of related-company use is the control exercised over the nature and quality of the goods or services." It also says "the key to ownership is the nature and extent of the control by the applicant," and that "Control over all of the related company's affairs is not required." You don't have to run your graduates' studios. You have to control what they teach under your name.

A license can be oral or written. The TMEP says "A controlled licensing agreement may be recognized whether oral or in writing." Written is far easier to prove later. I covered license terms in the article on licensing and quality control.

The risk: a license with no control

Here is the part that surprises method owners. The danger isn't that someone steals the name. It's that you give it away by not supervising it.

The statute treats a mark as abandoned when "any course of conduct of the owner, including acts of omission as well as commission," causes it to become generic "or otherwise to lose its significance as a mark." Omission counts. Doing nothing is a course of conduct.

The Ninth Circuit applied this in FreecycleSunnyvale v. The Freecycle Network in 2010. The Freecycle Network let local groups use its name and pointed to its etiquette guidelines and a noncommercial rule as quality control. The court said the noncommercial rule "says nothing about the quality of the services provided by member groups," and that guidelines the groups could freely adapt "cannot be considered an actual control." It held the network "engaged in naked licensing and consequently abandoned the trademarks." The court described naked licensing as a licensor that "fails to exercise adequate quality control over the licensee."

The court also looked at actual supervision, not paperwork. It said the lack of a written contract isn't conclusive, but the licensor must have "in fact exercised sufficient control over its licensee." For a method, that means the standards you write down have to be standards you check.

Option two: a certification mark

A certification mark is a different kind of mark. The statute defines it as a mark used by someone other than the owner "to certify regional or other origin, material, mode of manufacture, quality, accuracy, or other characteristics" of that person's goods or services. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1054, certification marks are registrable the same way trademarks are, by owners "exercising legitimate control over the use of the marks."

The TMEP lists the defining feature: "a certification mark is not used by its owner but rather by authorized users." It also says a certification mark "does not indicate origin in a single commercial or proprietary source." It tells clients the teacher meets your standards, not that you're the one teaching. The TMEP's examples include certification that a performer "meets certain standards."

The USPTO's guidance on certification mark applications says you file a copy of "the certification standards governing how the certification mark is used," and that a use-based application requires that you're "currently certifying the goods or services of others."

The catch with certification marks

A certification mark owner can't use that mark to sell its own services. The required statement in the application is that the applicant "is not engaged in the production or marketing of the goods or services to which the mark is applied." And a registered certification mark can be cancelled "at any time" if the owner "engages in the production or marketing of any goods or services to which the certification mark is applied," or doesn't control its use.

The USPTO adds that registering a certification mark "precludes the owner from registering the same mark as any other type of mark." So if your studio teaches classes under "Larkspur Method," that same name can't also be your certification mark. A method owner who teaches is usually looking at option one for the method name.

What this means for your teacher training

Before your first cohort graduates, decide which structure you're using and write it down. Then build the control into the program, not just the contract:

  1. Written teaching standards graduates agree to follow.
  2. A way to check them, like video review, observed classes or continuing education.
  3. A renewal cycle, so the right to use the name expires unless they stay current.
  4. A clear way to end someone's right to use the name.
  5. Rules for how graduates display it, so the name stays a brand and doesn't become the generic word for the workout.

Then watch the market. A name only stays strong if you notice when it's misused. I wrote about that in the article on policing your trademark, and about naming a program in the article on coaching program names.

If you want to talk through how to register a method name before you start certifying instructors, you can see how the search and filing packages work on the services page, and the FAQs page answers most of what comes up before a first call.

Book a free 15-minute discovery call with the attorney (opens in a new tab)

(No legal advice is given on the discovery call. It's a chance to tell me what you're building and hear how the process works.)

Sources

This article is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Start here